Fair is Fair 2024 | Withdrawal of Services
THE STARK REALITY FOR CRIMINAL BARRISTERS
Government have failed to honour their commitment to an independent review of fee rates.
Cuts ranging from 28.5% to 60% have been applied to fees from 2008 – 2011.
Two thirds of criminal barristers leave after just 6 years.
Other workers in criminal justice have had pay restored.
- In 2008, Government unilaterally broke the link between fees paid to barristers with increases applied under public sector pay agreements.
- This means that barristers are paid a flat rate, with no provision for inflation or cost of living increases, in marked contrast to those employed in the public sector.
September 2008 Non-payment of 2.5% increase (per public service pay agreement) March 2009 Reduction of 8% in fee levels (at the same time as FEMPI cuts imposed) April 2010 Reduction of 8% in fee levels (at the same time as FEMPI cuts imposed) October 2011 Reduction of 10% (no equivalent cut was imposed on the public sector) January 2024 10% fee restoration granted as part of commitment to an independent review and pathway to full restoration - The planned withdrawal in July is an escalation on the unprecedented action which was taken by barristers nationwide last October 3rd.
- The Bar of Ireland is seeking an independent, meaningful, time-limited and binding mechanism to determine the fees paid to criminal barristers by the Director of Public Prosecutions and under the Criminal Justice (Legal Aid) Scheme.
Already Delivering on Flexibilities
The flexibility delivered by barristers has enabled significant and valuable reforms to improve the experience of victims, their families and vulnerable witnesses; including but not limited to
- Implementation of Victims’ Rights Directive
- New measures to protect vulnerable witnesses
- New pre-trial procedures to assist victims of crime
These reforms simply could not have been implemented without the cooperation and goodwill of barristers.
Further Impacts Include
- Delayed justice due to a dearth of criminal barristers to deliver criminal advocacy services.
- The future pipeline of criminal barristers is already under strain.
- In addition, the public trust and experience of the criminal justice system relates directly to the strength of our rule of law.
For more information, view our press release.